El Deafo Review

Review by Chloe Anderson Written and Illustrated by Cece Bell Winner of the John Newberry Medal  SYNOPSIS  El Deafo is perfect for new readers as a bridge between sight-word books and more complex stories. It tells the story of Cece Bell, who loses most of her hearing at the age of 4. New schools and making friends can be scary […]

sequentialstate: Review: Dreamin’ Sun, vol.1 by Ichigo…

sequentialstate:

Review: Dreamin’ Sun, vol.1 by Ichigo Takano

Ichigo Takano is building a reputation in the United States as a mangaka of note; her comic orange was published in two omnibus editions by Seven Seas Entertainment and was nominated for an Eisner this year in the Best U.S. Edition of International Material—Asia category. This is Seven Seas’ first Eisner nomination, and the series garnered quite a bit of praise from both critics and readers. Now Seven Seas has licensed Dreamin’ Sun, a 10-volume shojo manga that originally ran in Shueisha’s Bessatsu Margaret. This is the same magazine that has published comics like Strobe Edge and Dengeki Daisy, both of which are popular Shojo Beat manga.

In Dreamin’ Sun, Shimana Kameko is a high school girl who is dealing with the recent death of her mother. Her father has married a younger woman and there’s a 6-month old in the house; Shimana feels like a stranger in her own home, and in a tense introductory moment, decides to pack her bags and run away from home. After running away, she runs into a 20-something lawer, Fujiwara Taiga, who runs a boarding house, and he offers her a room in exchange for $100/month rent and for meeting three conditions. She agrees, and moves in with Fujiwara and two high school boys her age, the feisty, rude, and bratty Nakajou Zen, and the cool, collected, and kind Tatsugae Asahi. 

Dreamin’ Sun bounces between a traditional shojo style and a more sketchy, cartoony style that’s played for laughs. The book looks like it’s setting itself up to be a love-triangle comedy, although during the first volume it’s basically introducing all the key players and establishing a mood. Despite the book’s dense layout and panel structure, it at times feels empty – there are plenty of panels with a single figure staring into the distance, with some small screentone effect applied, and the result is that there’s quite a bit of empty space in the book. The panel structure isn’t as inventive as some of the recent comics I’ve seen from Bessatsu Margaret, and at times the screentone and other effects feel like filler rather than emphasizing the emotional heft of the book.

Throughout Dreamin’ Sun, Takano explores the grieving process, and focuses on building family. Shimana isn’t really that bad off at home, and she loves her step-mom and little brother. She leaves not because she’s abused, or because her dad ran out on his debts, like so many other runaway manga, but because she’s afraid accepting this new reality will betray the memory of her mother. Takano’s depiction of altered grieving here is especially keen, and while the comic is mostly fun and games, making lunches, and doing silly exercises,

Shimana must confront her parents after she runs away, and she is never allowed to hide from her problems for too long.

There’s an element of family and responsibility that runs throughout the manga that gives it some stickiness and some weight. 

I think Dreamin’ Sun succeeds most in its writing; Takano’s characters are strongly realized, and while they slot into some familiar territory, they aren’t cookie cutter shojo. Most love triangles have a clear favorite, and while Shimana starts out liking Asahi, it’s not clear to me that he’s the favorite to win the long game. While the art and panelling of Dreamin’ Sun’s first volume is probably best described as workmanlike, its strong writing, thematic heft, and clean pacing make it a strong debut volume, and hopefully a sign of things to come.


If you liked this review and want to see more manga reviews at Sequential State, please support our Patreon!

A great review for one of our newest series. The first volume of Dreamin’ Sun is available now!

Yuri Manga: Hana & Hina Afterschool, Volume 1 (English)

Yuri Manga: Hana & Hina Afterschool, Volume 1 (English):

[Feature] Consider the Lilies of the Field: The Case for Yuri Manga – Anime Feminist

[Feature] Consider the Lilies of the Field: The Case for Yuri Manga – Anime Feminist:

And she’s hosting a giveaway of several of our yuri books on Twitter, too! https://twitter.com/JLMKart/status/861334832604905473

Check out these reviews of Bloom Into You, Girl From the Other…

Check out these reviews of Bloom Into You, Girl From the Other Side, Kase-san, and Kindred Spirits on the Roof at the blog Soliloquy In Blue! 

http://soliloquyinblue.mangabookshelf.com/2017/05/04/several-from-seven-seas/

MARCH Review

By Eric Kallenborn Last August, I was privileged enough to hear Rep. John Lewis and Andrew Aydin, co-authors of the award-winning graphic novel trilogy March, speak at Evanston Public High School in Evanston, Illinois. It was there, about three months before the Presidential election that I understood, that no matter the outcome of the election, […]

Review: ‘The Girl from the Other Side: Siúil, a Rún’ Vol. 1 — Good Comics for Kids

Review: ‘The Girl from the Other Side: Siúil, a Rún’ Vol. 1 — Good Comics for Kids: